I was just communicating with a friend about which baton to
purchase for duty use as a security officer.
I decided that I can further voice my opinions and baton reviews here
for more people to ignore. Hopefully this
is a start of private security product reviews that I will to expand upon in
future posts.
First a small look into my background and why I feel I am
entitled to share my opinion about police batons: I have had training in baton use while in the
US Navy, at the Riverside County Sheriffs and the San Francisco Police Academy. I am a certified baton instructor from ASP
and Monadnock. I am also a certified master
baton instructor from G-tek. Most
importantly I have carried and used different batons while on duty to defend
myself and in one case defend another security officer.
BSIS used to regulate the type of baton you could
carry. BSIS did away with this
requirement and now only requires that you are certified in baton use and carry
a permit with you while on duty. There
are two main baton designs, the straight baton and the side handle. I have seen other baton designs such as the
Handler 12 and the Rapid Rotation Baton, but these are not that popular for
private security use.
The straight stick baton
The straight stick is self explanatory; it’s the oldest and
simplest baton design. They are often
made of hardwood, but in modern times are available in other materials such as
aluminum, acrylic, or plastic. The major
benefit of these batons is low cost; I have seen wooden straight stick batons
on sale for less than $10. Another
benefit is that the tactics required to use this type of baton are simple and
easy to use in combat. Use of a straight
stick is reliant upon gross motor skills and the officer only has to commit to
memory certain no-strike zones. Remember
a baton can be considered a deadly weapon if used as such.
The side handle baton (PR-24)
The side handle baton was introduced to the American law
enforcement community in 1958 by a former US Marine. The side handle baton is a baton with a
handle attached at a 90-degree angle near the gripping end. The concept for the side handle baton was
borrowed from the ancient Okinawans who used a similar side-handle stick called
the tonfa. One of the first and largest
suppliers of these batons was Monadnock and the model was the PR-24. The model number stuck and is now used to
reference most side handle batons.
There are advantages of the side handle baton over the
straight baton: Some officers may be
able to deliver a strike of greater power when used in conjunction with certain
techniques. There are a far greater
number of defensive maneuvers and take-downs that may be used. If the side handle baton is dropped, it
shouldn’t roll around on the floor and end up a tripping hazard.
I recommend the straight baton over the side handle for one
main reason, the techniques and tactics to use the side handle are complex and
hard to remember without regular practice.
Do you remember the last time you practiced with your baton against an
aggressor? In my experience when the
adrenaline is pumping and the fight is on, the side handle baton gets used more
often like a club. This is exactly what
got the LA police officers in trouble during the Rodney King beating. Another disadvantage is the extra bulk on the
duty belt. There are collapsible PR-24
batons of good quality, but only decrease about six inches of baton length and
are not much help in reducing bulk.
A note on collapsible straight batons
A collapsible baton is easier for an officer to carry and to
sit in a car wearing it. This is contrasted with non-collapsible batons, which
the Officer may, as a measure of convenience, often resort to removing from his
or her belt when seating themselves in a vehicle. What good is a baton if it’s left in the car
when you need it? The main problem with
most collapsible batons is the light weight of the baton. This translates to less power during
impact. Don’t get me wrong, these steel
batons sting like a mo-fo, but they lack the impact power of a traditional
straight stick. Because of this lack of
power the officer may have to make multiple strikes to gain compliance. There are some new collapsible batons
introduced to the market that are thicker and heaver than the popular ASP and
Monadnock models.
I hope to post detailed product reviews in the future. If you have an opinion please feel free to
email me or leave a comment on the blog.
Thanks and stay safe!